logo

Posting tweet...

Powered by Twitter Tools


Brutal call screws Red Wings, Time for NHL to change rule

November 19, 2009   ·   Derek Felix   ·   Jump to comments

By now, the hockey world knows what happened last night at Hockey Town between the Stars and Red Wings. If you saw it, then indeed you know how brutal it really was. Of course, we’re referring to one of the worst calls of all-time going against Detroit in a 3-1 home loss to Dallas.

It took place in the third period. With Mike Babcock’s club trailing 2-1, veteran enforcer Brad May sent a turn around backhand from the slot towards Star backup Alex Auld which he looked to have covered, resulting in a stoppage. But before you knew it, the Wings started celebrating because they saw what ref tandem Stephane Auger and Dennis LaRue didn’t. The puck was actually behind Auld trapped in a piece of the net beyond the goal line which the Red Wing broadcast on NHL Network confirmed. The play in question:

What was supposed to be the first stoppage of the third turned into chaos with Toronto headquarters quickly catching the same thing, phoning into Joe Louis to discuss the controversy. While each bench waited, a lengthy review resulted in LaRue referencing the “intent to blow the whistle” rule waiving it off. The problem was that the audio replays showed that the whistle blew three seconds after May’s shot was in hiding behind Auld, who sneaked it back to his pads.

After I shot it, I didn’t see it go in,” a disappointed May explained of what should’ve been a banner night that included an electrifying scrap he won over Krys Barch in the second. “But he [Auld] was trying to pick his foot up and it was in the net. I just saw a highlight of it and have no idea why it wasn’t a goal.

It wasn’t blown dead. It was a goal,” Babcock protested. “The guy never meant to blow the whistle. It was a shot.”

Clearly, both are right of a joke of a rule that usually comes into play for the wrong reason. How does the NHL explain to them that there have already been similar instances this year where initially goals didn’t count but then were overturned after going upstairs? The Rangers had one like that where conclusive replays showed the puck in against LA. It counted which of course didn’t satisfy Terry Murray.

Why not change the rule? If the whistle blows simultaneously or a split second after the puck’s in, then the goal won’t count. But in the event that it’s blown significantly after with it going to review, then it should count. The issue is that the league has an outdated rule which just needs to be refined. We’re only talking about a simple and well explained change that would satisfy everyone. No longer would there be such confusion.

The question is will the NHL consider it. They always are trying to tweak rules to improve the game. So, wouldn’t it be a novel concept to take a closer look at this rule which right now, is way too frustrating for players, coaches and fans who pay good money to see their teams?

We believe it’s time!

  • Share/Bookmark
readers comments
  1. Hasan on November 19th, 2009 8:27 pm

    You have to wonder, has officiating always been this bad and we’re just now finding out about it because of technology or has it for some fundamental reason got worse? Seems like in every sport we’re talking about declining officiating. Even the soccer World Cup qualifiers yesterday, France went through on a ridiculous goal that should have been waved off for a handball.

You must be logged in to post a comment.

NY Hockey Report

Thursdays at 11 p.m.

Rangers Schedule

Your sideblock text goes here

Islanders Schedule

Your sideblock text goes here

Devils Schedule

Your sideblock text goes here

Sabres Schedule

Your sideblock text goes here

At CTC Tickets, we don't just sell sports tickets, we get excited about them! Become a CTC fan on Facebook for discount and contest news announcements, and follow @CTCTickets on Twitter for opportunities to win gift cards and more.



Don't miss any of the NHL action in New York this year at the SBG Global! The online sportsbook offers live hockey odds, unique NHL betting options, numerous sports betting prop wagers including odds to win the Stanley Cup.



Looking for the best online sportsbook? Visit BangTheBook.com for the best bookmaker bonus code, and daily free football picks!

Visit the Online Gambling Paper for the best list of sports betting websites and great guide to the best casinos.



Learn more about the online casinos from this gambling portal. Whether the casino websites or the NFL odds are your vice, we've got you covered.

2009 Top 5 Picks 1.John Tavares, NYI 2.Victor Hedman, TB 3.Matt Duchene, Col 4.Evander Kane, Atl 5.Brayden Schenn, LA

Show what you know about the NY sports scene when you bet online.

Watch horses and riders battle it out at the world famous Cheltenham festival in England.

Sports Betting

The brand new 32Vegas Online Casino brings you the atmosphere of the exciting Vegas strip, straight into your living room.

New York Rangers
New York Islanders
New Jersey Devils Tickets
New York Giants Tickets

BetMyHorse.co.uk is a unique online horse betting portal offering rich information for betting online on horse racing, also provides in depth betting analysis & daily horse racing news articles.

Play your favorite online casino games anytime, anywhere at Blackpool Club, with the latest in flash technology.

eToro takes forex trading to a new level. The eToro platform is simple and comfortable to use, allowing you to focus on your trading.

Online diamond jeweler offering top quality rings, earrings and bracelets, with unique 3-D views of set or loose diamonds.

Joyland Casino welcomes you to the top online casino bonus on the Internet. Here you will find the best online casino games and bonuses.

Mister Gammon is a portal offering online backgammon players the latest information about backgammon tournaments and events.

Una guida ai casinò di alta qualità che ti offre tutto ciò che devi sapere riguardo alle ultime notize dei casinò online.

One of the largest premier guides to online slots machine and online slot games. A complete guide to playing progressive slot games.

Online poker Information with poker, news, videos, tournaments and reviews. Play Texas Holdem, Omaha, 7 Card Stud & 7 Card Stud Hi/Lo plus more online poker games.

(4) Pittsburgh def. (2) Detroit 4-3 Pens win 3rd Stanley Cup Evgeni Malkin, Conn Smythe CONGRATULATIONS 2009-09 STANLEY CUP CHAMPION PITTSBURGH PENGUINS


Improve the web with Nofollow Reciprocity.