Tue 6 May 2008
Won’t Get Fooled Again: Second Round disappointment must be addressed
Posted by Kovy274Hart under Henrik Lundqvist , Jaromir Jagr , Rangers1 Comment
Fool me once. Shame on you. Fool me twice. Shame on me. Like a great Who song, we “Won’t Get Fooled Again.”
In the Rangers’ case, they fooled not only themselves but many as well into believing a team with Chris Drury and Scott Gomez added to a veteran core which included Jaromir Jagr, Brendan Shanahan and Martin Straka would be good enough to contend for a Stanley Cup.
One Spring ago, they were very close to upsetting a more talented Buffalo roster but Drury and 7.7 seconds altered possible history. Having upgraded at center, the Rangers were not only hoping to take that next step but catch lightning in a bottle. Instead, what transpired was another poor start with Jagr unable to find chemistry with either new center. Neither’s style was conducive to the Czech’s East/West game a la Swedish pivot Michael Nylander, who worked well with No.68 and Straka to form a No.1 line the past two seasons before moving on to Washington.
The Rangers also didn’t plan on it taking a month for Gomez to get going and Drury, who grew up idolizing the club to not start playing until mid-January. Perhaps the latter put tremendous pressure on himself. Whatever the reason, he didn’t play to capability until the second half when suddenly the 31 year-old Trumbull, Connecticut native became the team’s most consistent performer tying Jagr for the club lead in goals (25) while pacing them in power play goals (12) and game-winners (7).
With his team’s best offensive player struggling to form chemistry with the top two pivots, Ranger coach Tom Renney tried the 36 year-old captain with promising rookie Brandon Dubinsky. Due to the former 2004 second round pick’s size, speed and strength, he worked much better with Jagr. The Rangers’ version of the Odd Couple which paired up players 15 years apart paid off because each used their size effectively on the forecheck giving opponents fits. It didn’t matter if Renney put the complementary Straka on the unit or deterrent Sean Avery cause both possessed speed and were diligent forecheckers.
One of the reasons the team underachieved in the first half were injuries to Avery and rookie energizer Ryan Callahan. It’s little secret that the Blueshirts were a different team with the 28 year-old Toronto native in the lineup. He not only distracted opponents but produced 15 goals and 18 assists for 33 points in 57 games, making it entirely possible that he could’ve wound up with 25 goals and 50 points if he’d not missed significant time. That certainly might’ve made a difference in the standings.
As for Callahan, the 23 year-old Rochester native wasn’t himself. Probably returning too early, he never resembled the aggressive attacking physical player he was last Spring, forcing the organization to send him back to Hartford where he regained confidence and scoring touch. When he returned, the former 2004 fourth rounder looked more himself earning Renney’s trust and becoming an effective penalty killer even scoring a crushing shorthanded Game One winner against the Devils in Round One.
In the second half, the Rangers also benefited from the surprising play of Nigel Dawes. Following a couple of brief stints, the former 2003 fifth round selection was sent down to Hartford. After tearing it up, he was recalled in January and became a mainstay in the lineup. More confident, the 23 year-old Manitoban began to harness his own talent scoring and setting up key goals. In his first full season, he finished with 14 goals, 15 assists for 29 points along with a club best plus-11 rating in 61 contests.
Another criteria for the club’s up and down first half was Henrik Lundqvist’s unsteady play in net. No doubt the respectable 26 year-old Swede was impacted by his father’s aneurysm last December. He also might’ve been affected by the uncertainty surrounding a new contract. Once both issues clarified, so did his play which resembled more of what a few spoiled Ranger fans had grown accustomed to. After establishing career bests in games played (72), goals against average (2.23) and shutouts (10), the Rangers’ 2000 seventh round steal was once more nominated for the Vezina.
With the team’s playoff status uncertain, Team President and GM Glen Sather didn’t make a big splash at the trade deadline instead unloading former top prospect goalie Al Montoya to ex-assistant GM Don Maloney’s Coyotes for spare part Fredrik Sjostrom. He also didn’t address the team’s glaring need for a power play quarterback opting to acquire defenseman Christian Backman from the Blues.
Though the team played their best hockey after the deals, it was only due to the elite players raising their level. While Sjostrom performed adequately bolstering the fourth line, the same couldn’t be said for Backman, who too often was an adventure in his end. Most disappointing was that after showing some offensive promise down the stretch, the 28 year-old Swede’s game vanished in the playoffs where somehow he didn’t register a point in eight games before Renney scratched him in favor of physical veteran Jason Strudwick.
It also didn’t help that Marek Malik never regained the affable coach’s trust. Even if the lanky defender wasn’t much of a physical detriment, wouldn’t he have been a better choice? He could’ve logged more time than Strudwick relieving pressure from the way overplayed and flawed Michal Rozsival, whose game fell apart against a bigger and faster aggressive Pens team.
Far too much pressure was placed on second-year defenseman Dan Girardi, who wore down. Partner Fedor Tyutin took a step back after a solid 2007 postseason, committing far too many mistakes and losing physical battles. When your best defenseman turns out to be promising rookie Marc Staal, it speaks to what was wrong with the 2007-08 Rangers. One day, the 21 year-old former 2005 first round pick could evolve into a Norris candidate. It speaks to the kid’s maturity and hockey instincts from a family of winners with possibly younger brother Jordan becoming the second sibling to win a Cup.
What must change is the lack of a true power play QB who could effectively run it and take pressure off the forwards. Due to Rozsival’s inability to shoot the puck, opposing penalty killers felt no sense of urgency opting to attack the other Rangers leaving the points open. Girardi was the only willing shooter netting five which was one fewer than the pass happy Rozsival.
Word of friendly advice to the coach. Sending out Tyutin to man a point is not a logical answer. Neither was “solution” Paul Mara, who hadn’t been utilized that way since his days in the Desert. The veteran was a solid soldier who developed into a reliable third pair defenseman but nothing more which is why it makes sense to let him go.
Another thing which became clear was that while the D did an adequate job in their end, they often struggled to get pucks out turning their zone into a Chinese fire drill. This also became evident while killing Pittsburgh power plays. The most defining example was when Jagr had just tied Game Three and Ryan Hollweg took an inexcusable boarding penalty. Close to killing it, a tired Ranger PK unit couldn’t get the puck out. They had ample opportunities but somehow the Pens kept it in which meant no chance to change resulting in a crushing Evgeni Malkin left point blast proving to be too much for them to overcome.
In their Game Five series elimination, the Rangers again failed to clear the puck with a diving Marian Hossa barely keeping it alive. The same end result with the Pens’ superior skill setting up the eventual OT hero with a tap-in.
Renney is a well received coach but one has to question the overall penalty killing strategy. Why did it take Lundqvist to tell his teammates to go after the Pens prior to Game Four, which coincidentally worked out much better? Most of the series, they had way too much space and setup time. Against that caliber talent of Hossa, Evgeni Malkin and Sidney Crosby, you can’t give them room to operate. Secondary scorers Ryan Malone and Petr Sykora are pretty good too as are defensemen Sergei Gonchar and Ryan Whitney.
The Rangers didn’t have the kind of mean defensemen who could clear the front of the net and make life difficult for the Pens’ stars. That also must get addressed. Do they overpay for Rozsival, who’s provided good mileage but isn’t equipped for that kind of yeoman work? Or is it finally time for Sather to take a good hard look and make the necessary changes to take this club to the next level?
The dilemma is that the Rangers have many decisions to make with their own potential free agents which include an uncertain Jagr with a possible return to Europe looming. If their best playoff performer decides not to comeback, who replaces him? Do they take a run after Hossa, who it should be noted has never been a reliable go-to player such as Jagr. Don’t believe us? See his body of work with predecessors Ottawa and Atlanta.
Perhaps the Rangers would be better off trying to get Jagr re-upped for a couple of years. He says he’s not done and believes he’s still got another four productive years left. The question is what does he want? Nobody can tell for certain. Czech buddy Straka’s status largely depends on what he does. The 35 year-old has been a good Ranger but this season missed 17 games and often passed up primary scoring chances.Do they bring him back or elevate a Dawes or Callahan?
One key veteran who probably won’t return is Brendan Shanahan. The classy 39 year-old had a poor second half and only scored one goal in the playoffs. The skating just wasn’t there and often slowed down Gomez, which is why Renney waited too long before elevating Callahan. The future Hall of Famer also was given too much responsibility particularly on a struggling power play where his shot got blocked a lot. It’s never easy to part with such a proud character player. At this juncture, Shanny was uncertain if he wanted to play a 21st NHL season.
What do they do with Avery, who is recovering from a lacerated spleen suffered in the first period of Game Three? Remarkably, the valuable agitator didn’t miss a shift before being rushed to St. Vincent’s Medical Hospital. His condition has since improved. It should take a while to recover but likely won’t impact a busy July where teams will be lining up for his services. It’s expected that he’ll command at least four million a year. The real question is does a player who enjoys the limelight want to stay? All could depend on Sather. He’s a hard negotiator and could use underhanded tactics which might push Avery away.
One player they should bring back is steady backup Stephen Valiquette. The 30 year-old vet performed admirably achieving career bests in games (13), starts (10), wins (5), GAA (2.19) and notching the first two shutouts of his career with both coming in Philadelphia. Re-signing the personable No.2 goalie who takes to his role well is a must.
Depending largely on what happens with Jagr and Avery will determine how much cap space the Rangers have to work with. Adding size and toughness up front and on the blueline are vital. They should go hard after current Pens Malone and Brooks Orpik. As for upgrading on the point, Brian Campbell wouldn’t be a bad option but at what cost? In his brief stint with San Jose, the ex-Sabre proved to be weak in his end. A cheaper alternative would be chasing Mark Streit from Montreal, who was quite productive playing up front while also manning the point. Or does the club re-sign Andrew Hutchinson (64 points in 67 GP with Hartford) and see if he can provide the missing point shot?
There also could be a few Hartford players who might be ready. Lauri Korpikoski’s debut in which he scored his first ever NHL goal Sunday was a look into the future. Figure the Finn to play at least on the fourth line next Fall. Another player the Rangers must look at is former 2003 first round pick Hugh Jessiman. The 24 year-old made strides with the Wolf Pack and should be re-signed. The former Dartmouth product has some of the size (6-6, 231) and toughness the current roster lacks.
On the blueline, both Ivan Baranka and Michael Sauer should get looks. Former 2006 first round pick Bobby Sanguinetti likely needs a season in Hartford. He would have to have a very strong camp to stay up similar to Staal. Other players in the system who could make noise are defenseman Corey Potter, winger Dane Byers along with centers Greg Moore and Artem Anisimov.
There sure is a lot of unfinished business for an organization which thought big. It’s about time they did what it took to take that giant leap forward.
The clock is ticking.







